FCC rejects uniform 15-year pension restoration rule for retired employees

Federal Constitutional Court says restoration of commuted pension must depend on retirement age and the formula prescribed under Punjab Pension Rules 1963.

ISLAMABAD: The Federal Constitutional Court (FCC) of Pakistan has ruled that a uniform 15-year period cannot be applied to restore the commuted portion of pensions for all retired government employees.

The court held that pension restoration periods must be calculated according to each employee’s age at retirement and the relevant commutation formula under the Punjab Civil Services Pension Rules, 1963.

A two-member bench comprising Justice Syed Hasan Azhar Rizvi and Justice Muhammad Karim Khan Agha announced the verdict in four appeals filed by former Punjab Road Transport Corporation (PRTC) employees.

The employees had retired under a golden handshake scheme in 1997, receiving half of their pension as a lump sum and the remaining amount through monthly payments.

They argued that their commuted pension should have been restored after 15 years in 2012 rather than 2017, seeking five years of outstanding pension benefits.

The appellants also cited the case of another retired employee, Mian Muhammad Ishaq, who had received restoration after 15 years.

However, the FCC observed that the decision in Ishaq’s case was binding only between the parties involved and did not establish a universal legal principle.

The court clarified that pension restoration must follow Rules 8.11 and 8.12, with arrears and applicable annual increases payable wherever legally due.

It also held that differences in restoration periods arising from retirement ages do not constitute discrimination under Article 25 of the Constitution.

The FCC allowed all four appeals through a short order dated September 23, 2026, setting aside the Lahore High Court’s earlier judgments.