Khurram Ijaz demands urgent policy overhaul to revive stagnant private sector investment

Citing alarming State Bank of Pakistan data on falling capital formation, the BMPP General Secretary warns that tax distortions, high tariffs, and speculative real estate are suffocating industrial productivity and export growth.

KARACHI: Khurram Ijaz, General Secretary of the Businessmen Panel Progressive (BMPP) and former Vice President of the Federation of Pakistan Chambers of Commerce and Industry (FPCCI), has issued a stark warning over the prolonged contraction in Pakistan’s private sector investment, calling for immediate structural policy adjustments to rescue the nation’s productive economy.

Referring to the latest report by the State Bank of Pakistan (SBP) titled Reviving Investment in Productive Sectors of Pakistan, Ijaz highlighted that total Gross Fixed Capital Formation (GFCF) has been on a troubling downward trajectory since the late 2000s. According to the central bank’s data, total GFCF fell from an average of 15.0 percent of GDP during FY06–11 to just 12.6 percent during FY22–26—a slump driven primarily by retreating private sector capital.

“Pakistan cannot achieve sustainable economic stability when capital is fleeing productive industries,” Ijaz stated in a strongly worded press release on Saturday. “The sharpest declines have hit Large-Scale Manufacturing (LSM), Information and Communications Technology (ICT), and transport and storage services. These are the exact sectors that drive technological spillovers, create skilled jobs, and expand our export base.”

Ijaz emphasised that investment in manufacturing and modern tradable services is vital for capital deepening and international competitiveness. Without vibrant private investment in these high-value sectors, Pakistan faces slow structural transformation, weak export diversification, and shrinking employment opportunities for its growing workforce.

Drawing directly from the SBP’s findings, the BMPP General Secretary pinpointed six critical bottlenecks stifling industrial expansion:

• Punitive Input Tariffs: Heavy tariffs and para-tariffs on raw materials, intermediate inputs, and capital equipment inflate production costs. Data shows that a mere one percent increase in upstream protection triggers a 0.63 percent drop in downstream firm productivity and a 0.51 percent fall in sales.

• Anti-Export Bias: Excessive protection of domestic final goods makes local markets artificially lucrative compared to international trade, stripping firms of the incentive to innovate or improve product quality. Consequently, World Bank estimates place Pakistan’s 2024 exports at just 10.4 percent of GDP—roughly half of its economic potential and far behind regional peers like India and Bangladesh.

• Credit Constraints and Uncertainty: Public-sector crowding out, scarce long-term financing, and recurring macroeconomic instability have raised borrowing costs, deterring long-term commitments to machinery and digital infrastructure.

• Regulatory Burdens and Informality: Complex compliance rules and uneven enforcement penalise formal expansion, trapping businesses in the informal sector where access to finance, technology, and skilled labour remains severely restricted.

• Infrastructure Deficits: Unreliable energy supplies, inefficient logistics, and inadequate workforce training continue to inflate operational risks, particularly within energy- and tech-intensive industries.

• Real Estate Tax Distortions: Favourable tax treatment has turned real estate into a speculative haven, drawing vital liquidity away from productive manufacturing and tradable services.

To reverse this damaging trend, Ijaz urged the federal government to adopt a targeted, five-point reform agenda immediately. First, policymakers must eliminate existing market distortions before introducing new subsidies—specifically by simplifying tariff structures on imported inputs and rationalising property taxes to curb speculative plot buying.

Second, public expenditure should prioritise essential shared infrastructure and vocational skill development rather than broad, ineffective tax concessions. Third, targeted state support must be directed towards machinery upgrades, technology adoption, and local supplier development.

Fourth, Ijaz demanded a unified single-window tax administration to drastically cut compliance costs and end the harassment of businesses dealing with multiple revenue agencies. Finally, he stressed that any fiscal incentives granted to industries must be strictly temporary and tied to measurable performance benchmarks, such as verified export expansion and productivity gains.

“The era of rewarding non-productive speculation while taxing industry to the brink must end,” Ijaz concluded. “If the government fails to lower input costs, ensure policy predictability, and level the playing field for exporters, Pakistan’s industrial stagnation will only deepen.”