Why raising taxes isn’t working: SBP calls for rate cuts and base expansion

The central bank says Pakistan must move away from higher tax rates and focus on broadening the tax base, while reducing reliance on indirect taxes to improve revenue collection.

KARACHI: The State Bank of Pakistan (SBP) has advocated lower tax rates and a broader tax base to improve the country’s tax-to-GDP ratio, warning that increasing tax rates alone is no longer generating sustainable revenue growth.

In its annual report on the State of Pakistan’s Economy for fiscal year 2025-26, the central bank said revenue growth in recent years had largely been driven by higher tax rates, an approach whose effectiveness now appeared to have diminished.

The SBP emphasised that broadening the tax base was essential to increase revenue collection, improve tax compliance and reduce Pakistan’s reliance on regressive indirect taxation.

The report cited Pakistan’s corporate income tax rate of 29%, which is higher than the optimal rate of 26% estimated for the country in research published by Mehmood et al. (2022).

Direct tax collection improves

The SBP reported that direct tax collection increased slightly as a share of GDP in FY26. Consequently, direct taxes accounted for a record share of total FBR tax collection, surpassing indirect taxes for the first time.

The improvement was primarily driven by higher collection through enforcement measures and tax demand rather than voluntary payments.

Collection on demand increased notably due to improved tax enforcement and the resolution of tax disputes by the tax administration. Meanwhile, voluntary tax payments remained at the previous year’s level, while withholding tax collection declined marginally in terms of GDP.

The report noted that withholding tax collection weakened despite higher rates on property sales, dividends from certain mutual funds and profit on debt.

The government also expanded the withholding tax net by withdrawing exemptions on digital transactions through e-commerce platforms and pensions.

However, four major withholding tax revenue sources negatively affected collection during FY26.

Withholding tax from bank interest and securities declined because of lower deposit returns following a reduction in weighted average deposit rates. Similarly, collections from electricity bills weakened due to negative quarterly tariff adjustments and the possible impact of increasing solarisation on grid electricity consumption.

Lower exports also contributed to reduced withholding tax collection, while tax relief provided to salaried individuals earning up to Rs3.2 million annually slowed growth in salary-related withholding taxes.

Indirect tax collection faces pressure

Indirect tax collection declined slightly as a percentage of GDP during FY26, mainly due to weaker customs duty and sales tax receipts, while federal excise duty (FED) collection remained broadly stagnant.

The SBP attributed slower sales tax growth to reduced revenue from electrical energy following negative quarterly tariff adjustments and lower electricity consumption during the fourth quarter.

FED collection remained almost unchanged, partly because higher cigarette prices may have encouraged consumers to shift towards informal brands, reducing sales in the formal sector.

Customs duty collection also declined marginally as a share of GDP despite higher imports.

The central bank linked this development to tariff rationalisation under the National Tariff Policy 2025-30, which reduced customs duties on several tariff lines and revised concessional rates.

The changes affected revenue from imports of iron and steel, boilers and machinery, organic chemicals, paper and plastics.

Furthermore, slight appreciation of the rupee offset some of the impact of higher import volumes on tax collection.

Consequently, growth in taxes collected at the import stage slowed to 13.2% in FY26, compared with 23.4% in FY25.

Tax base expansion measures

Despite weaker growth in some indirect tax categories, the SBP acknowledged that measures to broaden the tax base provided support to revenue collection.

These included withdrawing sales tax exemptions on imported and locally supplied solar panels, removing exemptions on local supplies of iron and steel scrap, and expanding the sales tax scope to several imported items.

The central bank described these tax rationalisation measures as steps in the right direction, saying they could reduce tax expenditure and strengthen government revenue.

The SBP’s assessment highlights the need for Pakistan to pursue broader tax reforms, focusing on bringing untaxed sectors and activities into the tax net rather than depending primarily on higher rates imposed on existing taxpayers.