The central bank warns that Pakistan’s manufacturing sector is losing its role as an engine of economic growth before the country reaches higher income levels, threatening productivity, exports and employment generation.
KARACHI: The State Bank of Pakistan (SBP) has highlighted premature deindustrialisation as a major structural challenge for the country’s economy, warning that manufacturing has stagnated and is losing its traditional role in economic transformation.
In its annual report on the State of Pakistan’s Economy for fiscal year 2025-26, the central bank said Pakistan’s manufacturing value added (MVA) as a share of gross domestic product (GDP) had remained largely stagnant between 1960 and 2023.
The manufacturing sector recorded a slight increase in its contribution to GDP until the mid-1990s, followed by a gradual decline since the late 1990s. Similarly, manufacturing employment grew slowly from the 1990s and remained relatively stagnant after 2017.
The SBP said these trends suggested that Pakistan was either approaching premature deindustrialisation or had already entered this phase.
Premature deindustrialisation occurs when manufacturing’s contribution to GDP and employment peaks at lower income levels than those experienced by advanced economies during their industrial development.
The report noted that Pakistan’s structural transformation had stalled, with economic activity shifting towards low-value services without a corresponding expansion in manufacturing.
Factors behind premature deindustrialisation
The SBP identified five major factors that can contribute to premature deindustrialisation.
These include outsourcing of services by manufacturing companies, rapid productivity improvements that reduce labour requirements, participation in global value chains (GVCs), declining household demand for manufactured goods relative to services as incomes rise, and weak industrial foundations.
In Pakistan’s case, outsourcing has become increasingly common, with manufacturing businesses relying on specialist providers for human resources, recruitment, legal services, cleaning, catering and other activities. Some firms also outsource manufacturing work to suppliers of informal labour.
However, the SBP said rapid productivity growth in manufacturing did not appear to explain Pakistan’s experience. Similarly, the country had not achieved substantial integration into global value chains because of an anti-export bias.
Among comparable economies, Pakistan was identified as the only country experiencing both low and declining manufacturing value added as a percentage of GDP alongside low manufacturing exports relative to GDP since the late 1990s.
The report also highlighted that household spending on services appeared to be increasing faster than expenditure on manufactured products as per capita income rose.
Weak industrial infrastructure, limited capital, inadequate technology, skills shortages, insufficient innovation and ineffective industrial and export policies were identified as additional constraints.
Reversing deindustrialisation becoming difficult
The central bank cautioned that reversing premature deindustrialisation remained possible but had become increasingly difficult for low- and lower-middle-income economies.
Global manufacturing is becoming more technology-intensive, reducing its ability to absorb labour on the scale experienced during earlier industrialisation periods.
The SBP said cheap labour alone was no longer a sufficient competitive advantage. Modern manufacturing requires skilled workers, technological capabilities, efficient infrastructure, strong institutions and continuous innovation.
Climate change, geopolitical fragmentation and changing global supply chains are also increasing investment requirements.
Furthermore, the growing integration of services into manufacturing requires investment in advanced information and communication technology (ICT), research and other high-value services.
The report stressed that Pakistan faced the additional challenge of lacking a ready-made policy model for reversing premature deindustrialisation.
Manufacturing slowdown threatens employment
The SBP warned that premature deindustrialisation could significantly weaken Pakistan’s ability to generate productive employment and sustain long-term economic growth.
Manufacturing traditionally creates direct and indirect employment while supporting technological advancement, innovation, economies of scale and export competitiveness.
Countries including Japan, South Korea, China and Vietnam achieved significant economic transformation by developing competitive manufacturing and industrial sectors.
Manufacturing has also historically provided employment opportunities for low- and moderately-skilled workers, an important consideration for Pakistan, where a large workforce requires productive job opportunities.
The central bank warned that agricultural productivity improvements could create additional pressure on the labour market by reducing the need for workers in the sector.
Although surplus agricultural labour could move into services, Pakistan’s growing reliance on low-productivity informal services has limited wage growth and productive employment opportunities.
Meanwhile, high-productivity services cannot absorb workers on the same scale as manufacturing.
The challenge is particularly significant given Pakistan’s young and rapidly expanding labour force, which will continue to increase demand for employment in the coming decades.
The SBP’s findings highlight the importance of rebuilding Pakistan’s industrial base, improving technological capabilities, developing workforce skills and strengthening export competitiveness to support sustainable economic growth and job creation.