Blake Lively’s legal battle with her It Ends With Us co-star and director Justin Baldoni has taken another unexpected turn after newly released court documents revealed a private exchange between the two.
According to the filings, Baldoni visited Lively’s New York home in December 2022 while she was pregnant. What began as a casual conversation about her pregnancy allegedly shifted toward the topic of whether her unborn son would be circumcised. During this exchange, Baldoni reportedly volunteered personal information, stating that he himself was circumcised.
Conversation Occurred in Presence of Others
The documents emphasize that the remark was made in a room where multiple people were present, including Lively’s husband Ryan Reynolds, along with household nannies and assistants. Lively’s legal team argues that this moment contributed to a work environment that made her feel uncomfortable during the filming of It Ends With Us.
Lively Claims Boundary-Crossing Behavior
The A Simple Favor actress maintains that Baldoni’s comment reflected a broader pattern of conduct she believed crossed personal boundaries. Her lawyers argue that the incident supports her push to take the case to trial, asserting that the atmosphere around the production felt inappropriate and unprofessional.
Baldoni Denies Allegations
Baldoni’s legal team has denied all accusations, insisting the conversation was harmless and taken out of context. They argue that Lively is using normal interactions to build what they describe as a “false narrative.” His lawyers have requested that the court dismiss the case, claiming there is no evidence of the behavior she alleges.
Trial Set for March 9, 2026
Despite the defense’s request, the judge has scheduled the trial for March 9, 2026, giving both parties additional time to prepare for what is expected to be an intense legal showdown. The newly disclosed details have increased public attention and added further complexity to an already high-profile dispute.