Pkrevenue.com

Author: Faisal Shahnawaz

  • Protest on June 10 against plan to abolish zero-rate sales tax

    Protest on June 10 against plan to abolish zero-rate sales tax

    KARACHI: Textile value added sector has announced to stage protest on Monday June 10, 2019 against proposed plan to abolish sales tax zero-rating for export sector.

    Muhammad Jawed Bilwani, Chief Coordinator for Five Zero Rated Export Sectors in a statement on Saturday said that the exporters and manufacturers would stage peaceful protest outside the Karachi Press Club and would also hold a press conference to explain the negative impact of this proposed plan.

    The government reportedly decided in principle to abolish zero rating for five export oriented sectors especially for textile from the next budget 2019-2020.

    According to estimates prepared by the FBR, the total value of domestic and exports stood at Rs3 trillion out of which approximately Rs1.2 trillion was exported while remaining share of Rs1.8 trillion being consumed into the country.

    The rate of GST might be less than 17 percent as the FBR considers that the higher rate at initial stage would create more problems so the rate might be fixed lower than the standard rate.

    Earlier in a joint press conference on May 28, 2019 the Chairmen of Value Added Export Sector Associations stated that discontinuation of zero rated status will result in ruin and disaster of export oriented industries, flight of capital, mass unemployment and huge foreign exchange losses.

    It will also lead to corruption in connivance with dubious FBR officials under the mode of flying invoices, over invoicing, frauds in refunds etc.

    Further, due to significant volumes of liquidity being stuck in the form of sales tax refunds, export growth will be severely affected and we may even witness a decline in exports.

    More than 200 billion rupees of exporters in Refunds of Sales Tax, Customs Rebate, Withholding Tax, DLTL & DDT are already held up with Government.

    They also conveyed serious apprehension on proposed abolition of Final Tax Regime (FTR) for exporters.

    The Chairmen and Representatives of Council of All Pakistan Textile Mills Associations, Pakistan Apparel Forum, Pakistan Hosiery Manufacturers & Exporters Association, Pakistan Textile Exporters Association, Pakistan Bedwear Exporters Association, Towel Manufacturers Association of Pakistan, Pakistan Cloth Merchant Association, Pakistan Knitwear and Sweater Exporters Association, Pakistan Denim Manufacturers & Exporters Association, All Pakistan Textile Processing Mills Association, Pakistan Readymade Garment Manufacturers & Exporter Association, Pakistan Cotton Fashion Apparels Manufacturers & Exporters Association, The Surgical Instrument Manufacturers Association of Pakistan, Pakistan Leather Garments Manufacturers & Exporters Association, Pakistan Tanners Association, Pakistan Sports Goods Manufacturers & Exporters Association, Pakistan Carpet Manufacturers & Exporters Association, All Pakistan Bedsheets & Upholstery Manufacturers Association have fervently appealed to continue the Zero-Rating Scheme in the national interest to uplift exports. The five zero rated sectors are already documented and contribute 70% of total Nation’s exports and generate 50% of total Nation’s employment.

    They added that collecting sales tax and then refunding – is a futile exercise which creates hassles for exporters and also opens flood gates of corruption. No collection and no refund of sales tax from five zero rated export sectors is a tried and tested formula for increasing revenue and exports. We must not forget that during last two decades the Government had tried to undo zero rating twice but miserably failed, hence, zero rating was reintroduced. The zero rated scheme, in consultation with stakeholders, can further be improved for much better outcome.

    They added that the Government rather than involving in futile exercise of collecting sales tax and then refunding should focus its energy on increasing the number of taxpayers. According to FBR, in year 2017 number of active taxpayers was only 1.13 million only (0.51% of total population).

    They warned that Government’s attempt to collect interest free money in shape of sales tax will put the country’s export at stake. Today, in this period of worst economic crisis, can we afford to do away with zero rated status for the five export oriented industries? they questioned. They cautioned that if the Zero-Rating Scheme is discontinued, 30 percent of the export will decline in first year. They urged the Government to broaden the tax-base rather than burdening the existing tax-payers and documented sectors of the economy.

    Pakistan rupee has been devalued approx. 20.16 percent against dollar from 123.6 to 149.07 in just 9 months. Such state of affairs when the dollar is appreciating and banks are also reluctant to fix dollar rates, the Textile Exporters will be aggrieved in case of BMR because some machineries are delivered in 6 to 8 months and cost of machinery is increased to 20% during the period. Previously, on assurances of the Government to continue zero rating, exporters made huge investment in shape of BMR.

    They articulated that the Government focused on enhancing exports and identified the Five Zero-Rated Export Sectors as the main engines of growth for this purpose whereby Power Division vide Notification SRO12(I)/2019 dated 1st January, 2019 has revised the power tariff for zero rated industrial consumers to net 7.5 cents / kwh and OGRA vide Notification dated 18th October 2018 has been fixed Gas tariff for Registered Manufacturers or Exporters of five Zero-Rated sectors and their Captive Power to Rs600/- per MMBTU but discontinuation of zero rating status from the five export sector will put all the hard efforts of the government in vain.

    The Federation of Pakistan Chambers of Commerce & Industry, Karachi Chamber of Commerce & Industry, Lahore Chamber of Commerce & Industry, Faisalabad Chamber of Commerce & Industry & Sialkot Chamber of Commerce & Industry have also supported the stance and demand of Value Added Export Sector Associations to continue zero-rating scheme for the betterment of economy and export enhancement.

  • Economic Survey 2018/2019 to be launched June 10; GDP growth likely at 3.3 percent

    Economic Survey 2018/2019 to be launched June 10; GDP growth likely at 3.3 percent

    ISLAMABAD: The ministry of finance will present Economic Survey for 2018/2019 on June 10 (Monday) under which the GDP growth may be announced to fall 3.3 percent against the target of 6.3 percent.

    The government, however, set the economic growth at 4 percent for the next fiscal year.

    The economic survey may show a slide in manufacturing sector growth by 0.3 percent. The government sets target of two percent for 2019/2020.

    Large Scale Manufacturing (LSM) has shown negative growth of 2 percent in the ongoing fiscal year against target 8.1 percent. The LSM growth target has been set at 2.8 percent for next fiscal year.

    Services sector growth fell by 4.7 percent against growth target of 6.5 percent in the fiscal year 2018/2019. Services sector likely to show growth of 4.8 percent in 2019/2020.

    Construction sector exhibited negative trend, drop by 7.6 percent against the target of 10 percent for the current fiscal year. The growth target for construction sector has been set at 1.5 percent.

    Agriculture sector growth remained flat at 0.8 percent against the target of 3.8 percent. However, the present government sets 2.9 percent growth target for the next fiscal year.

    Main commodity recorded a slide of 6.5 percent. Main commodities production for 2019-20 set at 3.5 percent.

    Other commodities output increased by 1.5 percent. In 2018-2019 target set 3.5 percent, for 2018/2019 target was 3.5 percent.

    Cotton output has decreased by 12.7 percent against growth target of 8.9 percent. Cotton output target has been set at 3.1 percent in 2019/2020.

    Livestock grew by 3 percent against target of 3.8 percent. Meanwhile, growth target for livestock for 2019-20 set at 2.5 percent.

  • Salary income threshold may be revisited after huge tax loss

    Salary income threshold may be revisited after huge tax loss

    ISLAMABAD: The government may restore threshold of taxable salary income to June 30, 2018 level in the budget 2019/2020 after facing Rs50 billion revenue loss in the current fiscal year and considering difficult economic situation in the year ahead.

    Sources said reverting tax rates for salary persons to the June 30, 2018 position was under consideration for budget 2019/2020. However, no decision in this regard has been taken so far, the sources said.

    The new threshold may be between Rs600,000 and Rs800,000 for tax exempt income and further tax slabs may be notified accordingly, the sources said.

    In Finance Act, 2018 the rates of taxes upon salary income were considerably reduced and the threshold was increased from Rs.400,000 to Rs.1,200,000.

    However, in order to ensure income tax return filing a token tax of Rs1,000/year was imposed on salary persons deriving income between Rs400,000 and Rs800,000 and tax of Rs2,000/year was imposed on persons deriving salary between Rs800,000 to Rs1,200,000.

    These changes brought about a substantial decrease in the withholding taxes collected through various government and private withholding agents.

    Revenue impact of this change remained Rs.32.4 billion during the period from July 2018 to February 2019, according to a report of FBR sent to ministry of finance.

    It is estimated that total revenue loss on this account would be around Rs.50 billion in the current Financial Year, it added.

  • FBR to target large taxpayers for detailed field audit

    FBR to target large taxpayers for detailed field audit

    ISLAMABAD: Federal Board of Revenue (FBR) to conduct tax audits of large taxpayers, who are selected through an automated risk-based tool.

    According to World Bank’s updated report on ‘Pakistan Revenue Mobilization’ said that according disbursement linked Indicators (DLI) the FBR required to conduct tax audits on cases selected through an automated risk-based tool, informed by analysis of integrated data from multiple sources.

    It sets targets for detailed field audits of large taxpayers, thereby making an efficient use of resources for the highest impact.

    Riskbased audit is essential to deterring tax evasion and increasing compliance, especially for large taxpayers who use complex tax evasion techniques.

    It also benefits compliant taxpayers, as it spares them the hassle and cost of ineffective mass audits and reduces the discretion of FBR officials to pick cases for audit.

    The World Bank program also required the FBR to implement—through licensed agents—electronic production monitoring for high-risk sectors (e.g., sugar, cement, fertilizer) and electronic tracking of production, distribution, and sale of final products (tobacco, beverages).

    It will increase compliance by reducing the risk of under-declaration of output, sales, and corporate profits, the report said.

    The DLI related to new taxpayers with taxable incomes/sales identified through automated data sharing and ICT-based BI

    (number)will ensures that the FBR will use the new ICT equipment and software that enables the BI and data mining tools to identify unregistered or noncompliant taxpayers.

    It also disincentivizes the registration of individuals and firms without taxable income or sales, thereby avoiding inefficient use of FBR resources and negative impacts on micro firms and economically weaker households.

  • President summons NA budget session on June 10

    President summons NA budget session on June 10

    ISLAMABAD: President of Pakistan has summoned the budget session of the National Assembly (NA) on June 10, 2019.

    A letter of the national assembly secretariat on Friday said that the President has been pleased to summon the 11th session (Budget 2019/2020) of the National Assembly to meet in the Parliament House, Islamabad on Monday, June 10, 2019 at 4:00 p.m.

  • Any duty increase on beverages to result in industry closure: Siraj Teli

    Any duty increase on beverages to result in industry closure: Siraj Teli

    KARACHI: Siraj Kassem Teli, director of Pakistan Beverage Limited (Pepso Co. franchisee), while using platform of Karachi Chamber of Commerce and Industry (KCCI) raised voice against government’s proposed plan for implementing excise duty on beverage industry.

    Teli, who is also chairman of Businessmen Group (BMG) and former President of KCCI, warned the government against hike in duty on beverage industry and said that any such action would lead not only to closure of the industry but also resulted in mass unemployment.

    In a letter sent to Prime Minister Imran Khan, while referring to the ongoing buzz in the media and government circles about additional and new taxes including health tax and water surcharge being imposed in the next budget on beverage industry, he stated that this industry is already paying Rs100 billion to the national exchequer by way of output tax through FED and Sales Tax while the net revenue collection by the government comes to around Rs60 billion per annum which is apart from income tax, with-holding taxes, super tax and other provincial taxes.

    He pointed out that over the years, beverage industry and its products have become a necessity of life as many Pakistanis do not have access to pure drinking water and this industry is providing them safe water and other beverages produced with state of the art machinery by strictly following global hygienic standards.

    “We understand that the country is in dire need of additional revenue but one should realize that this new revenue must come from new sources and even if it is taken from old sources then it needs to be justified according to their capacity to pay otherwise it may jeopardize the existing revenue”, Siraj Teli stressed, adding that the Beverage Industry is already heavily taxed and if more burden is put on the industry, its growth, which is already in a declining mode in the first quarter, may suffer more.

    He said that the cost of doing business has already gone up due to other import/ regulatory duties and upsurge in dollar rate etc. while as this industry produces consumer products, more burden will be passed on to the consumers.

    Chairman BMG cautioned that there is a high chance that the imposition of new taxes may lead to closure of the industry resulting in jobs losses of hundreds of thousands of people across Pakistan, besides hampering Prime Minister’s efforts to bring more foreign investment to Pakistan because of such anti-business measures.

    He elaborated that this is an industry where supply side of economics should follow where more revenue is generated with growth, wherein taxes are reduced along with consumer prices that would lead to quantum growth and appreciation in net revenue as well. Any proposal to increase taxes will reverse the growth and it would start declining, ultimately reducing the revenue already being achieved from the Beverage Industry and above all high taxes are incentive for evasion, he added.

    Siraj Teli was of the opinion that today’s policy is actually shrinking the economy whereas the Government should have imposed a complete ban for one or two years on luxury items such as cars etc. and on those items which are being manufactured in Pakistan along with such food items without which we can survive.

    “Also controlling inflation by increasing interest rates has a negative impact on new investment and industry. The solution lies in more industrialization only”, he added.

    He said, “We at Pakistan Beverage Ltd. are in this business since the inception of Pakistan and are the highest tax payer in the Beverage and Food Industry for the last 40 years.

    “We believe in a prosperous Pakistan, we believe in paying due taxes and we are there to help and support your initiatives.

    “However, unjustified and excessive taxation will result in closure of the industry and put a significant dent in the existing revenue that is being collected by the government.

    “This will also result in reduction of employment of hundreds of thousands of job across Pakistan in the industry along with the allied retail businesses.”

  • PTBA advises revisiting arrest, prosecution law under sales tax

    PTBA advises revisiting arrest, prosecution law under sales tax

    KARACHI: Pakistan Tax Bar Association (PTBA) has advised the Federal Board of Revenue (FBR) to revisit law related to arrest and prosecution under Sales Tax Act, 1990.

    In its tax proposals for budget 2019/2020, the apex tax bar said that under the existing law, every director and officer of the Company is liable to be arrested if the officer has reasons to believe that such director or officer is personally responsible for actions of the Company contributing tax fraud.

    Accordingly, a person who is a nominee director or employee director can be held responsible for the liability of the company.

    The PTBA said that as per interpretation of the law nominee or employee directors be who are not involved in the administrative matters of a taxpayer are being held responsible for the liability of the taxpayer.

    “It is a trite law that before any coercive action is taken against any person; it is the duty of the Revenue Officer to provide proper opportunity of being heard and pass a judicious order to establish that the act of the registered person is willful and there was an element of mens rea.”

    In the Income Tax Ordinance, 2001 such matters are covered under Section 139 thereof which comprehensively deals with the liability both in case of company and association of Persons. “Section 139 needs to be replicated in the Sales Tax Act, 1990 on the similar lines.”

    The PTBA said that the proposed amendment would protect interest of the nominee/employee directors.

    Pointing out the issue of recovery of arrears under sales tax law, the PTBA said under Section 48 which deals with recovery of arrears does not provide any time limit to initiate the recovery proceedings.

    “By virtue of section 45B of the Act, a registered person aggrieved by any decision, may file an appeal within thirty days of the date of receipt of the order. On the contrary, under Rule 71 of the Sales Tax Rules, proceeding of recovery of impugned tax may be initiated after thirty days from the date of order.”

    In addition, recovery proceedings may be initiated as soon as Commissioner Inland Revenue (Appeals) confirmed the Order under Section 45B of the Sales Tax Act or Section 33 of the Federal Excise Act.

    The PTBA said that the section 45B, 48 and the rule are not harmonized. Sometimes order is served to the registered person after many days of the date of order and the recovery proceedings may be initiated under the Rule even if the time limit provided for filing of the appeal has not lapsed.

    Therefore, it is recommended that Rule 71 should be amended to provide commencement of recovery proceedings after thirty days from the date of receipt of the order.

    Similarly, time limit of 30 days from the date of receipt of the order should be provided in section 48 to bring harmony between the Act and Rules.

    The PTBA suggested that thirty days shall also be allowed for initiation of recovery proceedings in case demand is confirmed by the Commissioner Inland Revenue (Appeals) while disposing appeals filed under section 45B of STA and 33 of FEA.

    Giving rationale to the proposal, the PTBA said that it would keep harmony between the Act and the Rules in the spirit of natural justice.

  • FBR urged to reduce withholding tax for FMCG distributors

    FBR urged to reduce withholding tax for FMCG distributors

    KARACHI: Federal Board of Revenue (FBR) has been urged to reduce withholding tax rate to 0.2 percent for distributors of Fast Moving Consumer Goods (FMCG) companies as higher rate is increasing the cost of doing business.

    The Overseas Investors Chamber of Commerce and Industry (OICCI) in its tax proposals for budget 2019/2020, said that the distribution of FMCG is a high turnover and low margin business.

    This fact has also been acknowledged to some extent by the FBR by prescribing minimum taxation rate for the distributors of FMCG Companies at 0.2 percent of their turnover i.e. reducing the basic rate of minimum tax by 80 percent.

    The OICCI suggested that the basic rate of withholding tax under section 153 for distributors of FMCG sector should be reduced to 0.2 percent in line with section 113 of income tax ordinance, 2001.

    Giving rationale, it said that the high rate of withholding tax is increasing the cost of doing business as the existing withholding tax rate is higher than the net margin of distributors.

    Another proposal, the OICCI said that ‘Aerated waters’ is the only item within food and beverage industry that is subject to both sales tax (third schedule of the Sales Tax Act, 1990) and FED (First Schedule of Federal Excise Act, 2005), while all other beverages (like: Juices, Tea & Milk based drinks) are only subject to sales tax at 17 percent.

    Earlier in 2011-2012, FED rate was reduced from 12 percent to 6 percent with commitment that it shall be eliminated in 2 to 3 years but this was not implemented.

    The OICCI recommended that the Federal Excise Duty (FED) should be decreased from 11.5 percent to 8.5 percent, and eliminated gradually.

    The chamber pointed out that after the withdrawal of 58R of Special Procedure Rules, 2007, relating to the payment of Extra Tax on Specified Goods vide SRO 608(I) 2014 dated 02/07/2014, Large Trading Houses are now unable to issue sales Tax Invoice to Customers.

    Resultantly, all Professional Customers are inclined to directly purchase from Manufacturers as they are issuing Sales Tax Invoice to their Customers.

    Therefore, it recommended that Rule 58R which was withdrawn vide SRO 608(I) 2014 be restored only for Large Trading Houses operating as Wholesale-cum-retail under Chapter-XII.

    Giving rationale, it said that it would create level playing field for Large Trading Houses.

    The OICCI also submitted proposal for input Sales Tax on purchase of electrical and gas appliances.

    The Sales Tax Act, 1990 does not permit adjustment of Input Sales Tax on purchase of electrical and gas appliances (including visi-coolers & industrial gas appliances etc.) under section 8(1)(h) of the Act.

    The Act should be amended to allow for adjustment of such input sales tax.
    Visi-Coolers are an integral part of beverage business and inadmissibility of input tax places beverage business at a disadvantage vis-à-vis other businesses, besides such inadmissibility escalates the cost of doing business.

    In other industries, it is reiterated, that all input tax relatable to ‘taxable supplies made or to be made’ is admissible. Removal of restriction shall provide level playing field.

    The OICCI on the issue of further tax on sales to retailers, said with reference to section 14 of the Act, retailers are required to obtain sales tax registration excluding those retailers who are required to pay sales tax through their electricity bill.

    Moreover, as per section 3(1A) further tax at the rate of 3 percent is to be charged where supplies are made to unregistered person other than those mentioned in SRO 648 dated July 9, 2013.

    Therefore it is recommended that retailers who pay their sales tax through electricity bill to be excluded from further tax through inclusion in SRO 648 dated July 9, 2013.

    It will clear the ambiguity regarding applicability of further tax on these retailers.

  • FBR to reduce withholding tax provisions under World Bank program

    FBR to reduce withholding tax provisions under World Bank program

    ISLAMABAD: Federal Board of Revenue (FBR) is required to reduce number of withholding provisions to strengthen the income tax and take out this system from indirect taxes.

    According to funding approved by the World Bank for Pakistan Revenue Mobilization Project, the FBR is required to reduce the scope of withholding regime.

    The World Bank said that the funding requires a reduction in the types of transactions subject to income tax withholding.

    “It contributes directly to transparency of the tax system, given that the withholding regime transforms income taxes into indirect taxes, which are less visible to taxpayers. It will also greatly reduce compliance costs for firms that have to act as withholding agents.

    The World Bank also approved funds for transparent tax system for Pakistan. The World Bank said that under this funding the authorities require detailed reporting of tax expenditure in the annual budget documentation with disaggregated information about the cost and beneficiaries of each exemption and concession.

    “It is important to broadening the tax base because it exposes the revenue foregone due to each exemption/concession, and the industries that benefit.”

    The World Bank also stressed on coordination of the FBR with provinces. Under this funding program the FBR needs to reach agreements with the provinces on automated sharing taxpayer information, the methodology for calculating GST input adjustments, and common updated property valuation tables.

    “This coordination will enable the FBR and the provinces to broaden their respective tax nets. Coordination can be facilitated through the newly established Fiscal Coordination Committee, comprising the federal and provincial governments.”

  • MCC Multan announces auction of confiscated vehicles on June 12

    MCC Multan announces auction of confiscated vehicles on June 12

    ISLAMABAD: Model Customs Collectorate (MCC) Multan has announced public auction of confiscated vehicles on June 12, 2019 to be held at Customs Dry Port, Multan.

    Following vehicles to be presented for auction:

    01. Nissan X Trial Jeep, Model 2001, Chassis No.NT30134875, Engine No. 475365A-QR20, 2000CC.

    02. Daihatsu Coure Car, Model -1990, Chassis No. JDAL200S000853247, Engine No. GKDS 659-CC

    03. Toyota Hilux Surf, Model 1990, Chassis No. LN130-0019025, Engine No. 2L-19023782446-CC

    04. Honda Civic Car Hybrid, Model 2008, Chassis No. JHMFD36206S204777, Engine No. FD3 1331-CC

    05. Toyota Passo Car, Model 2007, Chassis No. KGC10-0148658, Engine No. 1KR-FE 1000CC

    06. Toyota Corolla Car, Model 1992, Chassis No. AE100-3098323, Engine No. 5A-4677005 1498-CC

    07. Toyota Corolla Car, Model 1994, Chassis No. AE100-3250841, Engine No. 5AB-688138 1498CC