President Alvi directs bank to refund unfair recovery

President Alvi directs bank to refund unfair recovery

ISLAMABAD: The President of Pakistan, Dr. Arif Alvi has directed the Bank of Punjab to refund money to a family of a deceased person, which was recovered unfairly.

President Dr. Arif Alvi upheld a decision of the Banking Mohtasib of Pakistan (BMP) ordering the Bank of Punjab to refund an amount of Rs 423,556 to the family of a deceased borrower which the Bank had unilaterally and unfairly recovered from the family.

READ MORE: President Alvi rejects FBR plea in maladministration cases

The President observed that the bank unnecessarily complicated a routine matter as its own SOPs empowered it to give financial relief in such cases.

Late Mian Allah Wasaya had availed a loan of Rs 3 million in 2015 from the Bank of Punjab and deposited Regular Income Certificates (RICs) issued by the Central Directorate of National Savings, valuing Rs 3.5 million, as Liquid Security with the Bank.

On January 27, 2017, he passed away, and the Bank on its own encashed the RICs then worth Rs 4.155 million and charged a mark-up of Rs 480,489 till October 22, 2018, while the accumulated mark-up at the time of Wasaya’s death was only Rs 57,294.

READ MORE: Dr. Alvi orders action over misconduct with 82-year taxpayer

The widow of Allah Wasaya (the complainant) requested the bank to charge mark-up till the period her husband was alive and waive off the mark-up thereafter.

The Bank, however, did not accede to her request after which she approached the Banking Mohtasib for redressal of her grievance.

After hearing the case and perusing the available record, the Banking Mohtasib noted that at the time of death the principal outstanding amount was Rs 2.889 million and the accumulated mark-up was Rs 57,294 only.

In the given circumstances, it was the fiduciary responsibility of the bank to guide the legal heirs for adjustment of outstanding liability at this level against encashment of RICs, the BMP observed.

READ MORE: Dr. Alvi rejects banker’s plea in woman harassment case

It further noted that instead of exercising its statutory obligation to set off the loan against liquid security, the bank continued to linger on recovery and unnecessarily piled-up mark-up on the principal outstanding amount which was unfair as per the State Bank’s guidelines.

The Mohtasib termed the claim of the bank as absurd and unprofessional that the matter pertained to the year 2018 and its books have been closed, therefore, it was not in a position to provide financial relief.

It added that no rule, regulations, law, or accountant standard was referred which barred the bank to revisit the old/closed cases as such types of transactions were a routine matter.

The Ombudsman held that unilaterally charging and recovering mark-up without justification beyond Rs 57,294 was an injustice to the deceased borrower’s family.

READ MORE: Alvi praises FTO role in resolving taxpayers’ complaints

It ordered that the Bank had committed maladministration and malpractice by not exercising its rights without any valid reason even though holding fully cashable liquid security under the loan agreement documents and piling up mark-up liability unnecessarily.

The Bank, subsequently, filed a representation against this decision of the BMP with the President. The President upheld Mohtasib’s decision and held that Bank had not provided any justification to upset the original order of the BMP.

The representation is rejected as it is devoid of any merit and the bank had failed to discharge the burden and statutory liability cast upon it under the law, the President noted in his decision.