Federal Tax Ombudsman identifies VPN-based cyber intrusions, weak sales tax registration controls and fraudulent transactions worth hundreds of millions of rupees, directing FBR to implement 13 reforms within 60 days.
ISLAMABAD, November 20, 2026: The Federal Tax Ombudsman (FTO) has exposed serious security weaknesses in the Federal Board of Revenue’s (FBR) IRIS system, registration loopholes and fraudulent sales tax transactions involving a Karachi-based textile business, declaring prolonged departmental inaction a case of maladministration.
In an order dated November 18, 2026, concerning Complaint No. 17796/KHI/ST/2026, Federal Tax Ombudsman M. Zafar ul Haq Hijazi addressed unauthorised access to the IRIS account of M/s Geneva Thread, owned by Muhammad Sarfaraz Khan and located in Karachi’s Federal B Area.
The complainant alleged that cybercriminals hacked the company’s IRIS account and submitted fraudulent sales tax returns for October and November 2025, generating fictitious transactions worth hundreds of millions of rupees.
Fake Sales Tax Invoices Worth Millions
According to the FTO’s findings, the fraudulent October 2025 return, filed on November 21, 2025, showed purported supplies of double yarn worth Rs408.20 million, involving sales tax of Rs73.48 million, to the Defence Division in Rawalpindi.
It also recorded coal supplies worth Rs204.01 million, carrying sales tax of Rs36.72 million, to an individual, Izzatullah, in Quetta.
However, the Directorate General of Intelligence and Investigation-Inland Revenue (I&I-IR) and Regional Tax Office (RTO) Islamabad confirmed that neither the reported purchases nor corresponding sales tax withholding had taken place.
The November 2025 return, filed on December 25, 2025, contained additional fictitious transactions, including single yarn supplies worth Rs45.56 million, with sales tax of Rs8.20 million, to the Health Department, Government of Sindh.
Another transaction showed coal supplies worth Rs22.78 million, involving sales tax of Rs4.10 million, to M/s Faisal Brothers in Karachi.
The Sindh Health Department confirmed that Geneva Thread was not registered as a vendor and had no budget allocation for the reported procurement. The other purported recipients also disputed the transactions, alleging misuse of their credentials.
The investigation further identified M/s Crystal Petroleum (Pvt) Ltd as a second-tier beneficiary linked to the Rs204.01 million coal transaction.
FBR’s IRIS System Exposed to VPN-Based Intrusions
Technical records obtained from PRAL and I&I-IR Karachi indicated that the disputed returns were submitted through VPN services, with apparent internet endpoints in Jakarta, Indonesia, and Diba, United Arab Emirates.
The FTO observed that existing technical capabilities within the FBR and I&I-IR were insufficient to conclusively identify individuals operating behind VPN services using the available system logs.
The investigation also uncovered serious weaknesses in sales tax registration procedures.
M/s Crystal Petroleum was incorporated with the Securities and Exchange Commission of Pakistan (SECP) on July 10, 2025, and obtained sales tax registration from CTO-I Karachi the following day.
The FTO found that its registration as a wholesale trader bypassed mandatory approval and verification requirements under Rule 5 of the Sales Tax Rules, 2006.
CTO-I Karachi also failed to conduct the required post-registration scrutiny under Sub-Rule 5(6).
Furthermore, the company allegedly uploaded copies of its own registration profile instead of required supporting documents, including utility bills and tenancy or ownership evidence.
The FTO also identified discrepancies involving two directors listed on a modified Form 181 whose appointments had not yet been approved by the SECP.
Rs73.49 Million Input Tax Adjustment Disputed
Geneva Thread submitted bank statements and reconciliation records covering October 2025 to May 2026, maintaining that it had received no payments against the disputed supplies.
The complainant sought reversal or refund of Rs66.11 million in carry-forward input tax for October 2025 and Rs7.38 million for November 2025 under Section 66 of the Sales Tax Act.
The FTO directed the relevant authorities to address the company’s claim after establishing its non-involvement in the fraudulent transactions.
FTO Issues 13 Directives to FBR
The FTO issued 13 recommendations and instructed the FBR to submit its compliance report within 60 days.
Key directives include:
• Initiating suspension, blocking and recovery proceedings under Section 11E and Sales Tax General Order No. 12 of 2023 against identified beneficiaries, including M/s Crystal Petroleum, Faisal Abbas and Izzatullah.
• Directing DG I&I-IR to pursue criminal investigations under Section 37A read with Section 2(37) of the Sales Tax Act.
• Introducing multi-factor authentication and biometric verification for IRIS accounts.
• Making supervisory approval mandatory for changes to critical taxpayer information, including CNIC numbers, mobile numbers and email addresses.
• Introducing automated IP monitoring and validation systems to identify suspicious return filings.
• Reviewing Rule 5 of the Sales Tax Rules, 2006, and strengthening registration and verification procedures.
• Establishing a 30-day deadline for post-registration scrutiny and tightening controls over Form 181 modifications.
• Conducting quarterly reviews of newly registered companies and examining corporate fake-invoice cases reported during the preceding year.
The ruling highlights significant weaknesses in taxpayer account security and sales tax registration oversight, urging the FBR to strengthen digital safeguards and enforcement mechanisms to prevent fraudulent invoicing and protect legitimate businesses.