Tag: FPCCI

  • Importers face surcharges on overstayed consignments

    Importers face surcharges on overstayed consignments

    KARACHI: Federation of Pakistan Chambers of Commerce and Industry (FPCCI) has discussed the matter of overstayed consignments at warehouses which was causing surcharges on clearance to importers.

    FPCCI President Mian Nasser Hyatt Maggo on Thursday said that due to COVID-19 commercial activities are down causing overstay of consignments and subsequently facing surcharge on clearance. During the meeting of the FPCCI Advisory Council on Budget various issues were discussed including period of limitation of warehousing.

    The President FPCCI said that the economic slowdown, recession in the market and financial constraints due to COVID-19, importers are unable to clear their consignments in time which has led to a situation where large quantities of warehoused goods have piled up incurring heavy surcharge as no general concession has so far been extended by the Federal Government in this matter. The situation is also impacting substantial amount of revenue.

    During the meeting of the Advisory Council headed by Mr. Zakariya Usman former President of FPCCI issue of importers of raw material were presented who are facing problems due to their consignments lying in customs bonded warehouses beyond the period stipulated under section 98 of the Customs Act, 1969. The meeting resolved to approach FBR to consider grant of waiver of surcharge on overstayed consignments in order to alleviate the problems of the importers.

    Mian Nasser Hyatt Maggo President FPCCI said that the government under the present difficult circumstances may favourably consider the enhancement of customs bonded warehousing period limitation up 60 days so as to mitigate hardship of importers.

  • FPCCI demands restriction withdrawal on input tax adjustment

    FPCCI demands restriction withdrawal on input tax adjustment

    KARACHI: Federation of Pakistan Chambers of Commerce and Industry (FPCCI) has demanded the tax authorities withdraw restriction on input adjustment under Sales Tax Act, 1990.

    A statement issued on Wednesday said that Advisory Council of the FPCCI on budget found various laws and regulations that failed to generate much revenue on the other hand badly affecting ease of doing business ranking of Pakistan.

    Mian Nasser Hyatt Maggo President FPCCI in this regards has already communicated to the Prime Minister and other concerned ministries for such impediments that are negatively impacting economic growth.

    During the meeting Advisory Council of the FPCCI has decided to extend its full support and cooperation to the government which is struggling to improve economic environment under the adverse conditions created by COVID-19.

    The Advisory Committee during its first meeting analysed the hardships being created under section 8B of the Sales Tax Act, 1990, wherein a registered person is not allowed to adjust input tax in excess of ninety percent of the output tax.

    “This restriction not only restrains the taxpayer to claim its legitimate input tax but is also affecting the ease of doing business and thereby increasing the cost of business.”

    The Advisory Council under the Convenership of Mr. Zakariya Usman former President of FPCCI reviewed the whole scenario and after due diligence unanimously proposed that hardship and discrepancy created by Section 8B of Sales Tax Act should be removed in the adjustment of input and output tax by allowing 100 percent adjustment of input tax.

    Amendment in Section-8B of Sales Tax Act 1990 should be made in the coming budget to allow 100 percent adjustment of input tax against output tax to all registered persons in order to remove anomalies.

    Mian Nasser Hyatt Maggo President of FPCCI has categorically informed that the present global and domestic conditions are completely different; COVID-19 has changed the world economic situation dramatically as most of the businesses are struggling for their survival.

  • Business community hails decision to simplify tax laws

    Business community hails decision to simplify tax laws

    KARACHI: Business community has praised Prime Minister Imran Khan for issuing directives to the authorities for focusing on tax reforms, simplification of tax laws and plugging loopholes in existing tax system, a statement said on Sunday.

    Mian Nasser Hyatt Maggo President of the Federation of Pakistan Chambers of Commerce and Industry (FPCCI) lauded Prime Minister Imran Khans directives to focus on reform in tax regime, simplification of tax laws, plugging existing loopholes, reduction in discretionary powers of tax collectors, automation to bring transparency in tax system.

    He said that it is heartening that Prime Minister is equally concerned with the tax reforms for accelerated growth. He said that understanding of Prime Minister in this regard shows his deep insight on the issues that are impeding economic growth with great attachment to the business community of Pakistan.

    He further stated that the Prime Minister has rightly taken up the issue of reforms in tax regime. The structure of taxation in our country is regressive, with indirect taxes accounting for major of total federal government tax collection.

    Tax collection is also disproportionate; industry being overburdened with tax payment of more than 60 percent against about 20 percent size in GDP. The present tax structure is complex because of overlapping jurisdictions with different laws and frequent policy changes through on almost daily basis by issuance of instructions, clarifications, changes in rules, CGOs, STGOs, ITGOs.

    The income tax, GST on goods, customs duties, federal excises is collected by the FBR while GST on Services is collected by provincial Revenue Boards/Authorities which also fragments Pakistan into five business market economies.

    The withholding tax regime of over 65 in numbers is also problematic and businessmen have been made withholding agents to deposit the tax for FBR.

    The President FPCCI said that the tax returns should be simplified and easily understandable particularly for SMEs and make it single page document. The present system requires almost all the tax returns filing persons to have further burden of associating the service charges of tax consultants and lawyers due to complicated tax operating system.

    He also informed that he has already written letter to Prime Minister for considering various suggestions on required tax reforms including complex Income Taxation to change to Flat Rate Taxation, taxation system to induce investments, multiple sales tax to change to single stage sales tax across the Board with exemptions on food, live saving drugs, educational instruments. Further the low rate Custom duties without additional custom duties, regulatory duties are answerable to impeding connived smuggling, mis-declaration. The Appellate tax system should be converted into independent tax judicial system in conformance with the requirement of constitution to increase the trust of businessmen in the taxation system.

    Mian Nasser Hyatt Maggo said that taxpayers bill of rights, protection of businessmen against retaliations by tax officials and accountability of tax officials should constitute fundamental to the requirements of tax reforms. The FPCCI has been demanding withdrawal of discretionary powers vested with the tax officials to avoid their misuse as presently FBR has become show-cause generating machinery for existing taxpayers, as are being informed to us at large.

    He stated that to wipe-out corruption there is need to improve automation in tax system and develop local software and Apps with simplified system so that interaction of human resource should be reduced and strengthening of information technology system can combat issuance of connived bogus sales tax refunds which not only affect government revenue but also damage business community credibility and trust.

    Mian Nasser Hyatt Maggo the President of the federation of Pakistan chambers of Commerce and Industry appreciated that a very good move has been done by present government by separating tax policy unit under Ministry of Finance and not under revenucracy adjustment methods of FBR who are only making tariff rate adjustments and making changes in statutes on compulsions due to observations of High courts and Supreme courts during budgetary exercises.

    He said that may be this year the budgetary exercise if is done by tax unit in Ministry of Finance may lead to compliance with directives of Prime Minister on tax reforms.

  • FPCCI demands autonomy of FBR officials for immediate resolution of tax matters

    FPCCI demands autonomy of FBR officials for immediate resolution of tax matters

    KARACHI: Federation of Pakistan Chambers of Commerce and Industry (FPCCI) on Wednesday demanded autonomy of senior officials of the Federal Board of Revenue (FBR) so they take on spot decisions to resolve tax issues.

    In a statement, Nasir Khan, Acting President of the FPCCI said that the business community had raised many problems pertaining to duty and taxes but the tax machinery had shown either no response or given low priority.

    He said that the issue of CNIC still not resolved despite COVID-19, the issue has reduced business activities. He stated that numerous laws and regulations have been imposed on the business sectors while at highest level meetings the FBR officials are unable to responds which is not suitable just time consuming.

    “The highest level official should have autonomy to resolve and decide the issues being raised in the meetings.”

    During the meeting with Chairman FBR the working of the FBR was discussed which is not up to mark and no sign of any trade facilitation is seen.

    There is no representation of this apex body of trade and industry in the various crucial decisions being taken by the FBR i.e., formulations of the resolution committees and issuance of SROs without consultation.

    During frequent visits of Member IR (Operation) to the FPCCI Head Office wherein, a number of problems were put forward for decision but instead there should be any relief to the trade bodies no fruitful decision is made so that even a single problem is resolved.

    Instead to increase the net of the taxpayer the FBR machinery is engaged to squeeze the traders which are already under tax net. The seriousness of the FBR towards tax collections may be noted from the fact that there is no representation of the FPCCI in various committees.

    It seems that there is a wide communication gap between the apex trade body and the FBR Headquarters and if the position is not improved then the net results in progress to resolve trade related issues will be zero.

    While participating in the meeting Zakaria Usman, Convener, FPCCI Budget Advisory Council expressed that is in trade business for more than 50 years and still would like to see a economical budget to be implemented by the FBR instead of revenue oriented budget.

    FBR is lacking consistency in policies which change rapidly affecting the working of businessmen and the commodities are gone out of costing.

    The policy of FBR to squeeze the already registered taxpayers may be shifted to a mechanism to explore new taxpayers and avenues accordingly.

    He suggested a cascading system spreading on five steps which is more economical and tax oriented. Secondly the policy to issue SROs over the night may be come to an end forth with. Regarding valuation he shared his views that the system of valuation prevailing worldwide on the basis of scan prices may be adopted immediately instead to issue valuation rulings on the will of valuation directorate who issue such rulings without taking the stakeholder on board.

    He quoted the example of plastic scan where the valuation prices are issued by the plastic association and applicable evenly on all the importers. Prime Minister is keen to move the country towards industrialization.

    The formation of trade zones will certainly be helpful extending the required benefits for the industries working in these zones. But is it sorry to say that the goods intended to be used in tax free zones are pushed in the tariff areas thus affecting the traders who are doing business in the tariff area after paying the statutory rate of customs duties and taxes.

    He suggested that CNIC problem should be resolved on priority.

    Nasir Khan shared with the Chairman the idea of one window operation that all the taxes are collected on same place including its adjudication etc., so that the traders may not run from pillar to post for redressal of their problems.

    He said that the traders of Balochistan have problems with the intelligence on valuation issues. The trade bodies struggled and helpful to stop smuggling in the province. Another problem he pointed out regarding DTRE approvals that it takes days and month to dispose the DTRE applications.

    He also suggested that trade bodies may be taken on board and on transfer / posting of the officers so that the willing officer could be pointed out for smooth running of day to day issues.

    Hanif Lakhani, Vice President of FPCCI suggested review of SRO 1065 for industrial investment and the advantages may be given to the stakeholders as the advantages extending to reconstruction industry.

    Khurram Sayeed, Former Vice President of FPCCI congratulated the Chairman on the targets of tax collection for the last seven months. He said that tax net to be broadened rather than to impose new taxes on the taxpayers which are already registered.

    He pointed out a new practice of FBR to issue notices to the taxpayers for the last five years. The officials when contacted they say that the notices are system based and we will rectify the data accordingly. He also said that It is against the judicial norms that Income Tax Officer who issue notices for recovery conducts the hearing himself which should have been heard by a separate officer.

    Khurram Ijaz, Immediate Past Vice President of FPCCI supported the view of President FPCCI to establish a Help Desk of FBR in the FPCCI Head Office and requested the Chairman that at least this decision may be finalized today.

    He further suggested that there should be a meeting of FBR Officers with the FPCCI representatives within two weeks’ time to hear the trade bodies and to consider budget proposals.

    Engr. M. A. Jabbar, Former Vice President of FPCCI said that the consultation of FPCCI and FBR on tax matters is almost zero. It is high time to take decisions by FBR on then and there basis rather than to shift the matters on committees / sub-committees. If there are no changes in the system then one cannot expect improvement in the taxation system that is why we are more interested in a fixed tax system rather than the present one. 

    Sultan Rehman, Immediate Past Vice President of FPCCI informed that current notices of Section 82 being issued by IRS for late filing of returns may be withdrawn immediately keeping in view the COVID-19 pandemic.

    Shabbir Hassan Mansha, Convener, FPCCI Customs Standing Committee pointed out the chronic issue of non-cooperation of shipping companies as they are not accepting the delay detentions. He suggested to improve the provisions of Section 14A in the current Budget so that the dominance of shipping companies and terminal operators could be reduced.

    He requested for regulation of Port & Shipping Laws so that terminal operators and shipping agents may not be able to shift their responsibilities. Another issue is the rent of the containers which sometimes exceeded the price of container itself. He suggested that a copy of SROs / Notifications / Orders may be endorsed to the Manager, FPCCI FBR Affairs Wing so that prompt within time may be taken in the best interest of trade bodies.

    Haroon Farooqui former President KCCI pointed out a hidden lobby who is working for their agenda and disturbing the overall trade friendly atmosphere creating a gap between the trade and FBR. He said that unless SMEs are encouraged Pakistan will never achieve its goal towards prosperity and industrialization.

    Zeeshan, Sr. Vice Chairman of Pakistan Tea Association said that the imported tea is not marketed as such but it is blended with other quality tea to make it suitable with respect to its aroma and taste.  

    In the last Chairman thanked the participant for sparing their valuable time for discussion and assured that he will consider the idea to establish a Help Desk at FPCCI. He termed the idea to hold seminars on the subject of Budget Proposals and to improve tax laws.

    Nasir Khan the Acting- President of Federation of Pakistan Chambers of Commerce and Industry strongly urged to consider FPCCI proposals avoid policy of scraping them that will discourage trade bodies to participate in the process of budget formulations.

  • Tax help desk at FPCCI to be set up after consultation: Javed Ghani

    Tax help desk at FPCCI to be set up after consultation: Javed Ghani

    KARACHI: Muhammad Javed Ghani, Chairman, Federal Board of Revenue (FBR) on Monday said that a help desk to resolve tax problems of business community will be established at the apex trade body after consultation with FBR wings.

    He was replying to various issues highlighted by members of Federation of Pakistan Chambers of Commerce and Industry (FPCCI) during his visit at the Federation House.

    Muhammad Javed Ghani said that he has noted the matters at large given by the members of the trade bodies and said the FBR Help Desk will be established in FPCCI. “However, it requires consultation with various wings of FBR in order to open the desk for productive outcome.”

    He further informed that the reduced human interactions is our policy towards which we are working and even we have improved the recent refunds in less period than it was earlier, which nearly is 70 to 80 percent more than the preceding period.

    He also said that frequent and purposeful interaction with FPCCI is being recognized to be a good move in the objective development of the economy of the country.

    Mian Nasser Hyatt Magoo, President, FPCCI said that it is high time to have paradigm shift in the tax structure to induce investment, promote production and grow economy instead of present revenucracy which remains the focus of FBR.

    He said that constitutional and lawful position given to FPCCI through Act of parliament to represent the private sector of trade, industry and services which has been diluted by FBR through marginalized interaction with apex body.

    He added that hardly any response is given by FBR against matters of members of trade bodies referred to FBR.

    He further stated that the revenue generating agents are being ignored by FBR, which is against the obligation which it owns.

    President FPCCI said that instead of negotiating with institutional representatives of FPCCI, FBR is attending Para shooters who have no locus standii to represent private sector stakeholders.

    He said that FBR should not accord market practicing tax lawyers and tax consultants to represent FPCCI in the FBR various committees.

    Mian Nasser Hyatt Maggo, President FPCCI said that FBR must come back to its past position since decade to negotiate trade, industry and business matters with/through apex body.

    The FPCCI collects fiscal improvement proposals from all the members’ bodies of trade and industry and CCIs to consider the paradigm changes in the present taxation for promoting economy with incremental tax revenue on sustainable basis.

    The apex body and its working on financial and other issues, if are taken up seriously with higher percentage of acceptance with higher level of seriousness of FBR would be a possible solution to make the budget which conduct business in harmony instead of amongst present conflicts and contradiction.

    The attention of the FBR was invited towards present leverage to groups other than FPCCI, which is against the lawful representation which FPCCI enjoys.

    It was said that the SMEs being said to be backbone of economy is being practically ignored and the persons of powerful and in-person connected groups have replaced the representation in decision making at FBR level.

    The members from different trade bodies invited attention of FBR towards CNIC condition on sale which is counterproductive to required sales tax collection as well as impede the industrial production and markets sales.

    Nowhere in the world CNIC or identity is asked from buyers, Pakistan is the only example set by FBR causing problems in business, in specific promoting the agitations on street by the agents of sales of produce, the conducting of small business be settled in peace by removing by removing CNIC condition for buyers.

    The participants invited the attention of Chairman FBR that still the entry of raw materials in part II of 12th schedule of Section 148 of ITO has not been facilitated, which is in the exclusive domain of FBR to resolve.

    The attention was also invited towards glaring example of not  entering raw materials and sub-component imported by vendors under SRO 655 but on the contrary all the component imported by assemblers have been assigned part II of the 12th Schedule of Section 148.

    This high handedness that weaker and SMEs segment not being well connected in the FBR committees are not being accommodated for otherwise on high reasonable ground.

    Other manufacturers also claimed continued ignorance of their requests pending with FBR with zero response.

    Tax structure on import of tea requiring rationalization was also put to the notice of Chairman FBR. Notices have become multiplied after the split of IRS commissionrates from earlier single unit to changed multiple units has eroded the concept of facilitation through One-Window.

    The same showcase notice is now originating from various windows opened in IRS.  The attention of Chairman FBR was also invited by the FPCCI towards the requirement of independence of tax judicial system, which presently negates the constitution and is pending since long for implementation in order to be constitutional compliant.

  • SBP urged to extend refinance scheme for salary payments

    SBP urged to extend refinance scheme for salary payments

    KARACHI: Federation of Pakistan Chambers of Commerce and Industry (FPCCI) on Saturday urged the central bank to extend the refinance scheme which was introduced for businesses in order to reduce the adverse impact of coronavirus pandemic.

    The FPCCI said that the State Bank of Pakistan (SBP) should extend the refinance scheme by one year for payment of wages and salaries, launched to support employees and prevent layoffs due to the COVID-19 outbreak in Pakistan.

    FPCCI President Mian Nasser Hyatt Maggo appreciated the initiative of SBP; introducing schemes like salary payments, deferred loans, introduction of temporary economic refinance facilities etc. to resolve the cash flow problems of businessmen and industrialists.

    He added that these schemes helped many industrial and service oriented sectors to retain employees during the Corona pandemic period. Under this scheme, SBP has released Rs. 238 billion to the private sector.

    While commenting on the refinance scheme for payment of wages and salaries, the FPCCI chief said that the aim of this scheme is to prevent layoff by financing wages and salaries of employees (permanent, contractual, daily wagers as well as outsourced) for all kind of businesses except for the government entities, public sector enterprises, autonomous bodies and deposit taking financial institutions.

    Since the companies that availed this credit facility through banks have not been recovered from the devastating economic impact of COVID-19, it would be advisable if SBP extend this scheme for more one year.

  • FPCCI laments FBR’s non-serious behavior in taxpayers’ facilitation

    FPCCI laments FBR’s non-serious behavior in taxpayers’ facilitation

    KARACHI: The Federation of Pakistan Chambers of Commerce and Industry (FPCCI) has strongly criticized the Federal Board of Revenue (FBR) for its lack of responsiveness in addressing taxpayers’ concerns.

    (more…)
  • Customs reluctant to give WeBOC access to ANF

    Customs reluctant to give WeBOC access to ANF

    KARACHI: Brigadier Syed Waqar Haider Rizvi, Force Commander Anti Narcotics Force (ANF) said that the force has not direct access to export related documents on Customs online system i.e. WeBOC, according to a statement issued on Saturday.

    He said that ANF does not require any sort of undertaking or affidavit from a clearing agent or exporter. “If somebody from the terminal operators demands such a document then it is not under the instruction of ANF,” he said while talking to office bearers of Federation of Pakistan Chambers of Commerce and Industry (FPCCI).

    While responding to the issues raised by participants of the meeting, said that it is high time to put combined efforts into the development of the economy in Pakistan.

    He further informed that drug smuggling is a transnational crime. Federal Board of Revenue (FBR), Customs, Coast Guards, ANF and other departments are working under their authorities. “We do not receive BL, invoice, or other documents, and Customs are reluctant to permit us access to the WeBOC system,” he added.

    Mian Nasser Hyatt Maggo, President of FPCCI while welcoming Brigadier Syed Waqar Haider Rizvi, Force Commander Anti Narcotic Force Karachi stated that repacking of the exported goods after examination caused delays, cost and confidence of the buyers.

    The President FPCCI also appreciated the working of the force especially during the lockdown due to COVID-19. He added that the problems of the trade to the extent of 70 – 80 percent have been solved due to cooperation of the force officials.

    However there are still some problems being faced by the trade and industry such as repacking of the export cargo after examination by ANF.

    The export cargo after examination is usually stuffed and the worthy factory packing is disturbed due to which there are complaints from the buyers that the packing of the goods is not satisfactory.

    There is a need of updating the information of precursor chemicals within the ANF staff working at ports. This may be achieved with joint sessions of ANF and stakeholders.

    There should be a fixed time period by the ANF for breaking the seal of the container so that the clearing agent may line himself up for examination accordingly. This will also save the exporter from shutting out of his containers by the shipping agents and could be exported in time.

    The meeting was attended by Athar Sultan Chawla, Arif Jeeva Vice Presidents, Muhammad Ayub in charge of the port control unit Anti-Narcotics Force Khurram Ijaz, Waseem Vohra former Vice Presidents and Shabbir Mansha,

    Convener FPCCI Committee on Customs. Meeting was concluded with the presentation of FPCCI crest to the Brigadier Syed Waqar Haider Rizvi, Force Commander Anti Narcotic Force Karachi.

  • Turkish envoy holds meetings with FPCCI, KCCI members to boost bilateral trade

    Turkish envoy holds meetings with FPCCI, KCCI members to boost bilateral trade

    KARACHI: Consul General of Turkey Tolga UCAK on Tuesday held meetings with members of leading trade bodies of Pakistan to discuss possibilities of enhancing trade and commercial ties between the two countries.

    During his visit to Federation of Pakistan Chambers of Commerce and Industry (FPCCI) commenting on the proposals of FPCCI President Mian Nasser Hyatt Maggo, the Consul General informed that there will be an inauguration of the services of Cargo Train between Istanbul and Islamabad with transit time of 9-10 days. This initiative will go a long way in promotion of bilateral trade.

    He also offered to organize road show in Pakistan with attracting Turkish Products. He was optimistic that in the post coronavirus the volume of bilateral trade will be further enhanced for which we have to prepare ourselves and make plans of future activities.

    He assured his full support to the initiative undertaken by FPCCI and its JBC for the joint activities between both countries.

    During his visit to Karachi Chamber of Commerce and Industry (KCCI), Tolga UCAK stressed the need to encourage joint ventures in different sectors of the economy whereas Turkey can also assist in setting up a tram service system in Karachi, particularly at the coastal line of sea view, which would change the face of Karachi and become a tourists’ attraction.

    While expressing keenness to strengthen trade and investment ties between the business communities of the two countries, Turkish CG assured that the commercial section of Turkish Consulate in Karachi was ready to fully assist Karachi’s business & industrial community intending to improve trade and investment ties with their Turkish counterparts.

    To deal with trade-related conflicts and protect the interest of customers, he suggested to form a private-to-private sector committee between the two countries

  • Industry rejects shutting down gas supply decision

    Industry rejects shutting down gas supply decision

    KARACHI: Trade and industry on Monday strongly rejected the government decision of discontinuing gas supply for export and manufacturing sectors.

    The industry will face the ever severe situation in the wake of discontinuation of gas supply to captive power generation for general industry from February 01 and the export-oriented sectors from March 01, 2021 leaving severe impact on the economy and exports of Pakistan.

    This was stated by Mian Nasser Hyatt Maggo, President, Federation of Pakistan Chambers of Commerce and Industry (FPCCI) addressing a Press Conference.

    The President FPCCI also accompanied by President Karachi Chamber of Commerce and Industry Shariq Vohra and other business leaders.

    All the business leaders vehemently rejected the cabinet decision and appealed Prime Minister to revisit this decision in the best interest of the survival of industry and for enhancement of Pakistan’s export and creating employment in the country.

    He further went on saying that industry is already confronted with many challenges particularly with respect to procurement of long term orders for the exports.

    However, the Pakistan’s exports when witnessing a growth this decision has badly affected confidence of foreign buyers and asking for completion of their orders and it is apprehended the export orders are likely to shift elsewhere to the other competing countries.

    He also quoted that Pakistan utility tariff is comparatively very high than the other regional countries.

    He further said that transferring electricity from captive power to grid will take time and costly not feasible as the cost of electricity generated by our captive powers is lower than the cost involved in shifting to grid.

    Most of the industries were running on natural gas using boilers and regeneration system so it was impossible to be converted on the grid and change the whole appliances within one month.

    Mian Nasser Hyatt Maggo stated that the decision of Cabinet Committee on Energy (CCOE) appears to have been taken on non-professional advice and without consultation of main stakeholders that is businessmen and apex bodies. He further said that this decision will not only harm the economy of Pakistan but will also damage our image with international buyers which seem a conspiracy against the progress made by Pakistan in the last two years by the present government.

    While addressing the press conference, Shariq Vohra, President KCCI showed surprise on the decision and stated that they would not allowed K-electric sabotage Karachi’s progress and development and both representative from Karachi Chamber strongly emphasized that government should not take such decisions that create labor unrest due to closures of factories.