KARACHI: Privatizing an integrating and monopoly provider of an essential service (i.e. electricity) to over 20 million people was a policy mistake, said a letter written by an advisor to the Prime Minister on Power and Petroleum.
Tabish Gauhar, Special Advisor to the PM on Power and Petroleum, in his response to a letter written by the Federation of Pakistan Chambers of Commerce and Industry (FPCCI) stated that unbundle K- Electric (formerly Karachi Electric Supply Company) into separate generation, transmission and (more than one) distribution companies as opposed to handing over its management to yet another single buyer of an integrated utility company i.e. an unbundled KE should be managed by different set of private entities going forward to avoid monopoly control and single point of management failure or success.
“In hindsight, privatizing an integrated and monopoly provider of an essential service (i.e. electricity) to over 20 million people was a policy mistake,” Tabish Gauher said.
In response to FPCCI President, it is further stated that prior to unbundling, reduce the overall cost of electricity for KE (and, therefore, the implied subsidy burden on the government) by integrating its own generation units and its Independent Power Producers (IPPs) into the national network on the basis of economic order dispatch.
“This will also help absorb the excess and relatively cheaper power available in the national grid/pool for the benefit of the entire power sector (lower circular debt), consumers of Pakistan (lower tariff) and reduce the need for KE to set up additional, more expensive, power plants and its own and create space on its balance sheet to finance the augmentation of the Transmission and Distribution network,” it said.
“… our government has already started doing that by increasing power supply to Karachi from the national grid from 650MW to up to 2000 MW, subject to signing a commercial-based power purchase agreement that is still pending,” it added.
The letter sent to FPCCI president further noted that the ministry supported the recommendations presented by various industrial associations to provide choice of retail supply to all the KE’s end-consumers once its exclusivity / monopoly expires in 2023, as in other DISCOs, in line with government’s power liberalization policy.
